News

/ Taxes and Law in Poland

Goods fraud and CIT in Poland – when does a fraudulent transaction not generate taxable revenue?

Goods fraud and CIT in Poland – when does a fraudulent transaction not generate taxable revenue?

/
Date18 Nov 2026
/
Stay up to date Add us as a preferred source on Google
Add

Goods obtained through customer impersonation fraud may not generate taxable revenue under Polish Corporate Income Tax (CIT) rules.

Key results at a glance
1

In its judgment of 26 June 2026 (II FSK 838/25), Poland’s Supreme Administrative Court (NSA) found that no revenue due arose in the fraud case examined.

2

The legitimate French customer denied ordering or receiving goods worth PLN 87,527.85 (EUR 19,474), which had been obtained by fraudsters.

3

On 8 October 2026, the Director of the National Tax Information (KIS) confirmed that the Polish company was not required to recognise CIT revenue in the case examined.

4

Under Article 15(1) of the Polish CIT Act, sales proceeds never received for fraudulently obtained goods do not qualify as tax-deductible expenses.

5

Under Polish CIT rules, non-payment for a genuine sale generally does not remove the obligation to recognise taxable revenue.

Key takeaways

A genuine sale determines CIT revenue recognition

An enforceable claim for payment arising from an actual sale is central to assessing revenue due under Polish CIT rules.

An invoice alone does not establish a sale

An invoice naming a customer that neither contracted nor received the goods does not substantiate a genuine transaction.

Actual losses require a separate tax assessment

The costs of purchasing or manufacturing lost goods must be assessed separately from the sales proceeds never received.

Fraud documentation supports the tax position

Customer correspondence, transport records and statements from the legitimate buyer can help establish what actually occurred.

Goods obtained through fraud by someone impersonating a legitimate customer do not necessarily generate taxable revenue under Poland’s Corporate Income Tax (CIT) rules. In its judgment of 26 June 2026 (II FSK 838/25), the Supreme Administrative Court (NSA) held that revenue due does not arise where the legitimate customer neither entered into a contract nor received the goods, and the supplier has no enforceable claim for payment arising from the purported sale. The Director of the National Tax Information (KIS) confirmed this position in an individual tax ruling dated 8 October 2026. However, the sales proceeds never received cannot be treated as a tax-deductible expense. The ruling does not automatically apply to ordinary cases of non-payment for a validly completed sale.

Goods fraud and CIT in Poland is an important issue for businesses selling on credit terms, particularly in cross-border transactions. Where a customer fails to pay, the supplier must generally still recognise taxable revenue. The position may be different, however, where no genuine sale took place because the goods were obtained by fraudsters impersonating a legitimate customer.

The distinction was clarified by the Supreme Administrative Court in its judgment of 26 June 2026, case II FSK 838/25. The ruling is relevant to companies that have lost goods through fraud and need to determine whether issuing an invoice creates an obligation to recognise revenue for Polish corporate income tax purposes.


Goods obtained through customer impersonation fraud

The case examined by the NSA concerned a Polish manufacturer of refrigeration equipment that received an order from an individual claiming to be the commercial director of a French company.

Before entering into the business relationship, the Polish company carried out customer due diligence. It checked the customer’s registration details, status in the VAT Information Exchange System (VIES), and information about the person placing the order. It also obtained a credit limit of PLN 200,000 from its trade credit insurer.

The order covered equipment worth PLN 87,527.85 (EUR 19,474). The goods were dispatched to a designated warehouse in France, and transport documents confirmed their delivery.

The problem emerged after the payment deadline had passed. The French company whose details had been used to place the order denied entering into any contract or receiving the goods. It transpired that the signature and company stamp on the documents did not belong to the legitimate customer, and the designated warehouse was not operated by that company.

The Polish supplier reported the matter to law enforcement authorities. The fraud was subsequently also investigated by the French authorities. The company applied to the Director of the National Tax Information (KIS) for confirmation that, in the circumstances described, it was not required to recognise taxable revenue in respect of the fraudulently obtained goods.


Does goods fraud generate taxable revenue under Polish CIT rules?

Not necessarily. Where goods have been obtained through fraud and the legitimate customer neither entered into a contract nor received the delivery, revenue due within the meaning of Article 12(3) of the Polish CIT Act may not arise. The decisive factor is whether the supplier has an enforceable receivable arising from an actual sale.

Under Article 12(3) of the CIT Act, revenue from business activities also includes amounts due, even where payment has not actually been received. Consequently, non-payment alone does not eliminate the obligation to recognise taxable revenue. If a business genuinely sells goods but the buyer fails to settle the invoice, revenue generally arises regardless of whether payment is received.

However, the NSA explained that fraud involving the impersonation of a legitimate customer presents a different situation.

In the case examined:

  • The legitimate customer neither placed the order nor received the goods.
  • The party that took possession of the goods intended to obtain them fraudulently rather than purchase them.
  • The invoice issued did not document a genuine sale.
  • The supplier had no enforceable claim for payment against the customer named on the invoice.

The NSA held that, in these circumstances, handing over the goods could not be treated as delivery under a genuine sales transaction giving rise to revenue due.

The judgment was based on Article 12(3), read together with Article 12(3a), of the CIT Act, rather than a general exclusion from taxation for all transactions connected with criminal activity.


Unpaid invoices vs goods fraud – what are the key CIT differences in Poland?

For correct CIT treatment, it is essential to distinguish an unpaid invoice from a situation in which no genuine sale has taken place.

CircumstanceOrdinary non-paymentGoods obtained through customer impersonation fraud
ContractGenuine sales contractNo valid contract with the entity identified as the buyer
Recipient of goodsActual purchaserParty impersonating the legitimate customer
Claim for paymentGenerally existsNo claim for the purchase price against the purported buyer
CIT revenueGenerally arises despite non-paymentDoes not arise in the circumstances examined by the NSA
Significance of the invoiceDocuments a genuine saleDoes not document an actual transaction

This comparison illustrates why reporting a fraud does not, by itself, establish that no taxable revenue has arisen.

The supplier must first determine whether a genuine transaction took place and whether an entity is legally obliged to pay the purchase price. Fraud may also give rise to a separate claim for the return of goods or compensation for damages. However, this does not automatically create revenue due from the originally intended sale.


Why did the Polish tax authority initially reject the company’s position?

In its individual tax ruling of 7 June 2024, reference 0114-KDIP2-2.4010.227.2021.23.S/KW, the Director of KIS concluded that the company should recognise revenue corresponding to the invoice issued.

The authority argued that the CIT Act requires businesses to recognise revenue due even when payment has not been received.

According to KIS, the ongoing criminal investigation and circumstances of the fraud did not justify excluding the revenue at that stage. The authority indicated that a subsequent adjustment could be made after obtaining appropriate documentation confirming the conclusion of the proceedings.

The authority’s position was upheld by the Provincial Administrative Court (WSA) in Kraków in its judgment of 19 December 2024, case I SA/Kr 653/24.

The company lodged a cassation appeal. The NSA overturned both the WSA judgment and the individual tax ruling, finding that the provisions governing revenue due had been interpreted incorrectly.


What exactly did the NSA decide on 26 June 2026?

The Supreme Administrative Court held that, in the circumstances described, no revenue due arose in the year in which the fraudsters took possession of the goods.

The Court emphasised that the goods had been handed over as a result of criminal conduct by a third party. The company had not completed a genuine sale to the French business named on the invoice. The NSA also rejected the assumption that the supplier should first recognise revenue and only adjust it once the fraud had been confirmed.

Importantly, the Court did not apply Article 2(1)(3) of the CIT Act, which concerns income from activities that cannot be the subject of a legally effective contract. Instead, the judgment was based on the absence of revenue due within the meaning of Article 12 of the CIT Act.


New KIS ruling of 8 October 2026 confirms the NSA’s position

Following the NSA judgment, the Director of KIS reconsidered the company’s application and issued individual tax ruling 0114-KDIP2-2.4010.227.2021.33.S/KW on 8 October 2026.

The authority confirmed that the company was not required to recognise revenue from handing over the goods to a party impersonating a legitimate customer. At the same time, it maintained its rejection of the company’s position that the value of the lost goods, understood as the sales proceeds never received, could be treated as a tax-deductible expense.

The significance of this interpretation lies in the application of the NSA’s reasoning to the reconsidered case. It is not, however, a general tax interpretation covering every instance of commercial fraud.

Corporate income tax in Poland · Goods fraud

Goods fraud in Poland: Supreme Administrative Court reverses the tax position

Must a supplier in Poland recognise corporate income tax (CIT) revenue for goods taken by fraudsters impersonating a customer? Four decisions, two different answers.

PLN 87,527.85

EUR 19,474 · goods lost

A Polish manufacturer shipped refrigeration equipment to a warehouse in France. The French company named on the order denied any contract or receiving the goods.

7 Jun 2024

Director of the National Tax Information

Individual tax ruling

Recognise revenue

19 Dec 2024

Provincial Administrative Court, Kraków

Judgment I SA/Kr 653/24

Ruling upheld

26 Jun 2026

Supreme Administrative Court

Judgment II FSK 838/25

No revenue due

8 Oct 2026

Director of the National Tax Information

New individual tax ruling

No revenue due

Case-specific: the decisions do not automatically cover every fraud – or ordinary non-payment for a validly completed sale.

Source: Judgment of Poland’s Supreme Administrative Court of 26 June 2026, II FSK 838/25; judgment of the Provincial Administrative Court in Kraków of 19 December 2024, I SA/Kr 653/24; individual tax rulings of the Director of the National Tax Information of 7 June 2024 and 8 October 2026.


Can the value of fraudulently obtained goods be deducted for Polish CIT purposes?

The NSA judgment does not establish that lost sales proceeds can be deducted for tax purposes. The Court explained that revenue never earned is not an expense incurred to generate that revenue and therefore does not satisfy the requirements of Article 15(1) of the CIT Act.

On this point, the NSA did not accept the company’s arguments.

Two categories must nevertheless be distinguished:

  • Lost sales proceeds – the amount the supplier expected to receive from the buyer but never collected. This amount does not become a tax-deductible expense simply because fraud occurred.
  • Actual costs of purchasing or manufacturing the goods – these require a separate assessment under the rules governing tax-deductible expenses, including the circumstances in which the loss occurred and how it was documented.

In the judgment examined, the NSA considered the claim relating to lost sales proceeds. It did not comprehensively determine whether, or when, the actual costs of purchasing or manufacturing the fraudulently obtained goods could be deducted for tax purposes.

For businesses, this means that the revenue and cost implications of fraud must be assessed separately. The absence of revenue due does not automatically entitle a company to recognise a tax-deductible loss of any amount.

Polish tax law · After customer fraud

One fraud, four tax questions in Poland

When fraudsters impersonating a legitimate customer obtain goods from a business in Poland, the corporate income tax (CIT), cost and Value Added Tax (VAT) consequences each need their own assessment – as shown by 2026 rulings of Poland’s Supreme Administrative Court.

01

Corporate income tax (CIT) revenue

May not arise

Where the legitimate customer neither contracted nor received the goods and no genuine sale took place (judgment II FSK 838/25).

02

Lost sales proceeds

Not deductible

Revenue never earned is not a tax-deductible expense under Art. 15(1) of the Polish Corporate Income Tax Act.

03

Cost of the lost goods

Assessed separately

Actual purchase or manufacturing costs: the Supreme Administrative Court did not comprehensively determine whether, or when, they are deductible.

04

Value Added Tax (VAT)

Different provisions

Corporate income tax conclusions don’t apply automatically. In judgment I FSK 1641/23, the Supreme Administrative Court found no taxable supply in that case.

Source: Judgments of Poland’s Supreme Administrative Court of 26 June 2026, II FSK 838/25, and of 7 May 2026, I FSK 1641/23; Polish Corporate Income Tax Act.


How should businesses document goods fraud for Polish CIT purposes?

A company that has fallen victim to fraud should preserve documentation that makes it possible to reconstruct the transaction and demonstrate why no genuine sale occurred.

Relevant evidence may include:

  • Commercial correspondence, purchase orders and documents containing the purported customer’s details.
  • Customer due diligence records, including VIES checks and business register confirmations.
  • Transport documents and proof of delivery.
  • Statements from the legitimate customer confirming that it neither placed the order nor received the goods.
  • Records of the fraud report and actions taken by law enforcement authorities.
  • Accounting and tax records relating to the original recognition of the transaction.

In the case examined by the NSA, the relevant circumstances demonstrated that the legitimate customer had not participated in the transaction and that another party had taken possession of the goods. Merely presenting an unpaid invoice is not sufficient to establish that no taxable revenue arose.

Must criminal proceedings be completed before revenue can be excluded?

In the case examined, the NSA did not make the absence of revenue due conditional on the prior completion of criminal proceedings. Its assessment was based on the facts described in the application for an individual tax ruling, particularly the absence of a genuine sale to the customer identified.

This does not mean that documentation from criminal proceedings is irrelevant. Such records may help establish how the fraud occurred, identify the perpetrators and demonstrate that the goods were obtained without a genuine intention to purchase them.

It is also important to remember that individual tax ruling proceedings are not intended to establish the facts of a case. The tax authority relies on the circumstances presented by the applicant. In any subsequent tax proceedings, the actual course of events may be subject to verification.


What does the NSA ruling mean for Polish companies engaged in international sales?

Judgment II FSK 838/25 is particularly relevant to businesses accepting orders from new overseas customers, especially where transactions are arranged through electronic correspondence and payment is deferred.

The case demonstrates that even extensive customer due diligence may not always detect the impersonation of a legitimate business.

Verifying an EU VAT number or company registration details confirms certain information about the business, but does not, in itself, establish that the person placing the order is authorised to represent it.

From a CFO’s perspective, three areas of risk are particularly important: correct recognition of CIT revenue, documentation of the actual loss, and consistency between tax treatment and accounting records.

When fraud is discovered, businesses should examine not only the possibility of pursuing legal claims but also whether the invoice issued documents a genuine sale.

Where there is uncertainty about the CIT treatment of fraudulently obtained goods, businesses may benefit from tax advisory services in Poland provided by getsix®.


Does goods fraud also have VAT implications in Poland?

Yes. Fraud involving the transfer of goods may require a separate assessment of its consequences for Value Added Tax (VAT) in Poland.

In its judgment of 7 May 2026, case I FSK 1641/23, the NSA examined the VAT treatment of fraudulently obtained goods and found that no taxable supply of goods had occurred in the circumstances of that case.

However, conclusions concerning CIT should not automatically be applied to VAT. The two taxes are governed by different legal provisions, and the correct treatment depends on what actually happened in the transaction.

Where fraud occurs in cross-border trade, it may also be necessary to review documentation relating to intra-Community supplies of goods and previously submitted VAT returns.


What should a business do after falling victim to customer fraud?

The first step is to establish whether the business genuinely entered into a sales contract with the entity named on the invoice or whether the goods were taken by an unauthorised party.

The company should then verify whether it has an enforceable claim for payment of the transaction price and identify the documents supporting the actual course of events.

Only on that basis can it assess whether CIT revenue was correctly recognised and whether any adjustments to tax settlements are necessary.

The costs of purchasing or manufacturing the lost goods, together with the VAT consequences of the incident, require separate analysis.

For high-value transactions or cases involving unclear facts, obtaining an individual tax ruling may be helpful. Its scope should, however, correspond precisely to the circumstances described and the questions submitted.


Goods fraud and CIT in Poland – summary

The NSA judgment of 26 June 2026, II FSK 838/25, confirms that issuing an invoice and physically handing over goods do not always result in revenue due for Polish CIT purposes.

Where a supplier falls victim to fraud involving the impersonation of a legitimate customer and no genuine sale takes place, taxable revenue cannot automatically be assumed to have arisen.

This position was subsequently reflected in the individual tax ruling issued by the Director of KIS on 8 October 2026. At the same time, the decisions confirm that sales proceeds never received do not, in themselves, constitute a tax-deductible expense.

For businesses, the key priorities remain establishing the actual facts, preserving supporting documentation, and separately assessing the revenue and cost consequences of the fraud.


Sources:


getsixThis article was written by the getsix® Editorial Team
getsix® provides accounting, tax advisory, HR and payroll, and business consulting services, supporting companies operating in Poland. The getsix® Editorial Team prepares practical information that makes Polish accounting, tax, and HR and payroll matters easier to understand.

If you have any questions regarding this topic or if you are in need for any additional information – please do not hesitate to contact us:

Ask a question »

CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIPS DEPARTMENT

ELŻBIETA<br/>NARON - GROCHALSKA

ELŻBIETA
NARON-GROCHALSKA

Head of Customer Relationships
Department / Senior Manager
getsix® Group
pl en de

***

This publication is non-binding information and serves for general information purposes. The information provided does not constitute legal, tax or management advice and does not replace individual advice. Despite careful processing, all information in this publication is provided without any guarantee for the accuracy, up-to-date nature or completeness of the information. The information in this publication is not suitable as the sole basis for action and cannot replace actual advice in individual cases. The liability of the authors or getsix® are excluded. We kindly ask you to contact us directly for a binding consultation if required. The content of this publication iis the intellectual property of getsix® or its partner companies and is protected by copyright. Users of this information may download, print and copy the contents of the publication exclusively for their own purposes.

Our Recommendations

Our Memberships

Our Certification

Wojskowe Centrum Normalizacji Jakości I KodyfikacjiTÜV NORDTÜV RHEINLAND

Our Partnerships

Competencies