Withholding tax and foreign income in Poland – the Supreme Administrative Court decides how to calculate the withholding tax deduction limit
Under Article 20(1) of the Polish CIT Act, the foreign WHT deduction limit is based on foreign income, not gross revenue.
In its judgment of 28 May 2025 (II FSK 1131/22), the Supreme Administrative Court confirmed that the Polish CIT deduction limit is based on foreign income.
In the case examined, a US contractor withheld tax on the invoice amount for software licences without deducting the company’s costs.
The Supreme Administrative Court overturned the Warsaw Provincial Administrative Court’s judgment, rejecting the use of foreign revenue instead of income.
The Supreme Administrative Court ruled that the in dubio pro tributario principle did not apply in the case because the statutory wording was clear.
In its judgment of 29 May 2025 (I SA/Wr 918/24), the Wrocław Provincial Administrative Court also examined the distinction between foreign income and revenue.
Cost allocation affects the WHT deduction limit
Companies must account for costs attributable to foreign revenue under Polish tax rules when calculating foreign income.
Documented allocation methods reduce tax risks
Consistent cost allocation methods and supporting records help reduce the risk of tax adjustments and disputes.
Foreign WHT may not be fully deductible in Poland
The deduction available under Polish CIT rules may be lower than the withholding tax actually collected abroad.
Previous WHT calculations may require review
Companies that used revenue-based calculations should review previous settlements and align their methodology with Polish tax rules.
In its judgment of 28 May 2025 (II FSK 1131/22), the Supreme Administrative Court (NSA) confirmed that, when deducting withholding tax (WHT Poland) paid abroad from Polish corporate income tax (CIT), the deduction limit under Article 20(1) of the CIT Act is based on income earned in a foreign country, not revenue. The ruling concerned a company whose US contractor withheld WHT from the amount shown on the invoice. Below, we discuss the dispute, the positions of the Director of the National Tax Information (DKIS) and the Provincial Administrative Court (WSA), and the reasons for the NSA’s ruling.
In this article:
Licences, WHT on revenue and lack of cost records – background to the case
A limited liability company sells licences for its own software both in Poland and abroad, including to a contractor in the US. When paying remuneration for the licences, the American entity withholds withholding tax (WHT) from the amount shown on the invoice, i.e. from revenue, without taking costs into account.
In Poland, the company calculates CIT on its overall taxable income – it combines domestic and foreign revenue and then deducts tax-deductible costs. However, these costs are largely common to the entire business and were not recorded separately for each market, making it difficult to attribute them to sales in the US.
Against this background, the company requested a tax ruling: when calculating the limit for deducting tax paid abroad under Article 20(1) of the CIT Act, can revenue earned in the US be used instead of foreign income, given that the American contractor withheld WHT on revenue without deducting costs?
Two approaches to WHT deduction
The dispute stems from the wording of Article 20(1) of the CIT Act: the opening part of the provision refers to “income (revenue)” earned abroad, while the deduction limit refers exclusively to “income earned in a foreign country”. This distinction gave rise to two opposing interpretations.
Position of the Director of the National Tax Information (DKIS)
The Director of the National Tax Information concluded that Article 20(1) of the CIT Act bases the deduction limit exclusively on income earned in a foreign country. Therefore, where tax was withheld abroad on revenue, the taxpayer must, for Polish tax purposes, allocate the relevant portion of tax-deductible costs to foreign revenue in accordance with Polish tax rules. The foreign income determined in this way must then be used to calculate the deduction limit.
Judgment of the Provincial Administrative Court (WSA) in Warsaw
The court of first instance adopted the opposite approach: since revenue was actually taxed in the source country, it could be treated as income for the purposes of calculating the Polish deduction limit, particularly where no records were available to allocate costs to a specific market. The WSA also referred to the principle of resolving doubts in favour of the taxpayer (in dubio pro tributario).
Where do the interpretative doubts come from?
- Mixed terminology in the provision
The first part of Article 20(1) of the CIT Act refers to “income (revenue)”, while the deduction limit is defined using only the term “income”. This raises the question of whether revenue can be substituted for income in the calculation when WHT has been collected on revenue in the source country. - The nature of WHT
In practice, withholding tax is often levied on a gross basis – calculated on the invoice amount or revenue, without deducting costs. This raises the question of whether the Polish deduction limit should be based on that amount or on income calculated after allocating costs in accordance with Polish tax rules. - The law applicable to determining income
The question arises as to which rules should be used to determine foreign income: those of the source country or Polish tax regulations. - Financial effect
Equating revenue with income would result in a higher deduction limit, which explains taxpayers’ preference for this interpretation and the opposing position taken by the tax authorities.
The Supreme Administrative Court’s ruling: income, not revenue
The Supreme Administrative Court overturned the judgment of the Provincial Administrative Court in Warsaw and upheld the cassation appeal lodged by the Director of the National Tax Information. The Court ruled that, when determining the deduction limit, Article 20(1) of the CIT Act refers exclusively to “income earned in a foreign country”. This term cannot be equated with revenue, even where withholding tax abroad was collected on the amount shown on the invoice.
The Supreme Administrative Court emphasised the limits of statutory interpretation: the literal wording of the provision takes precedence, which is why the in dubio pro tributario principle does not apply in this case. Since the provision refers to income when determining the deduction limit, the taxpayer must calculate foreign income in accordance with Polish tax rules. In practice, this requires allocating the relevant portion of costs to revenue earned in the source country.
The Court also emphasised the distinction between “income” and “revenue” under Article 20(1) of the CIT Act. Although both terms appear in the opening part of the provision, the legislator refers exclusively to income when establishing the deduction limit. Replacing income with revenue at this stage is therefore unacceptable. The ruling is consistent with a more recent line of case law emphasising that foreign income must be determined under Polish tax regulations, regardless of how tax is calculated in the source country.
A similar issue was also examined in the judgment of the Provincial Administrative Court in Wrocław of 29 May 2025 (I SA/Wr 918/24), concerning the calculation of the deduction limit for tax paid in Malaysia. The case addressed whether foreign revenue could be treated as income for the purposes of Article 20(1) of the CIT Act.
What does this ruling mean for entrepreneurs?
- Determining foreign income according to Polish rules. Even if WHT has been collected on revenue abroad, foreign income must be determined for Polish CIT purposes by taking into account the corresponding tax-deductible costs, calculated in accordance with Polish tax regulations.
- Consistent methodology and documentation. It is advisable to describe the adopted cost allocation methods (e.g. revenue-based, hourly or project-based allocation) in the company’s tax and accounting policies and prepare a short methodological note supported by source data.
- Country-by-country calculations. The deduction limit and the amount deductible are determined separately for each jurisdiction. Combining multiple countries into a single calculation increases the risk of errors.
- Verification of double taxation treaties and WHT documentation. The applicable method of avoiding double taxation must be verified, and relevant supporting documents should be collected, including a tax residence certificate and confirmation that withholding tax was collected.
- Impact on budgets and tax risks. The deduction available in Poland may be lower than the amount of WHT collected abroad. The absence of a documented cost allocation methodology increases the risk of tax adjustments, interest and disputes with the tax authorities.
- Review of previous tax settlements. Companies that have used revenue-based calculations should review their current and previous WHT deduction calculations and ensure that their methodology is consistent with the applicable Polish tax rules.
The Supreme Administrative Court’s ruling confirms that, when deducting withholding tax (WHT) paid abroad from Polish CIT, the relevant reference point is income earned in a foreign country, not revenue. This requires allocating costs to foreign revenue in accordance with Polish tax rules and maintaining separate calculations and documentation for each country. The Court rejected the possibility of substituting revenue for income and ruled out the application of the in dubio pro tributario principle in this case. For entrepreneurs, the judgment highlights the importance of documenting cost allocation methods, reviewing previous tax settlements and maintaining complete WHT documentation.
getsix® supports entrepreneurs with withholding tax (WHT Poland) matters – helping companies organise their tax settlements, maintain compliance with regulations and manage tax risks arising from international operations.
If you have any questions regarding this topic or if you are in need for any additional information – please do not hesitate to contact us:
GETSIX TAX & LEGAL
Tomasz Nowak
Senior Tax Consultant
getsix Tax & Legal
***




